Welcome to the Half of It

The Watcher
Chelsea and Kate dive into the bizarre true story of 657 Boulevard — the New Jersey home that became infamous after its new owners began receiving unsettling letters from someone calling themselves “The Watcher.” We get into the letters, the suspects, the lawsuits, the theories, and the details that often get left out when the story is retold. It’s creepy, frustrating, and somehow gets stranger the deeper you go.